Tim’s Review

Tim Johnson

Customer Support
Quality of Product
Shipping and Processing


One of my favorite choices. puts out a quality product and currently the 3rd best site. We wish there support was more on par with the others as they can be a struggle to reach. It also seems like the owner is focusing on other sites and not putting as much attention to this as it needs. Still there may be slightly better choices but this is still a quality site for your money!



  • The ink quality was excellent.
  • The seal was gold foil (even though it wasn’t the same seal) as the actual diploma!
  • The package they used was the strongest of anyone.
  • The leather graduation folder was a nice added touch.
  • No misspelled word; a few grammar issues though.


  • It had a state seal which isn’t authentic because we requested a private school.
  • The state seal, although raised gold was clumpy and the inner-detail unrecognizable.
  • They put “College of Business”. Our school does not have a college of business.
  • There was an error in wording. They put, “on the in June” for the graduation date which makes no sense.

#3 Ranked Fake Diploma Site of 2024!

very good fake diploma websites

Personally, I really do love this website. It’s very clean and easy to navigate. The product images are also very sharp and easy to make out.

Our payment for a replica college diploma to Phony Diploma arrived on a Thursday. We could see that it had arrived because of tracking we had requested, but we had to send several emails asking management to check their mailbox. They were certainly weren’t on top of that. Had we not hassled them, we may have found ourselves waiting even longer for our diploma. Still, they did honor their 24 turnaround; as stated on their website and shipped our document 24 hours after verifying our money order. They confirmed payment on that following Wednesday and it shipped that next day, the Thursday. Not everybody will go through what we did with them ignoring our emails but for us, it started things off on the wrong foot.

We know nobody cares about that and the only question that matters is, “did the diploma come and did it look good?”. Before we get into that, we want to show that we really did by from these guys and we aren’t pulling your leg. This is a true and honest review.

Customer Service

Phony Diploma offers live chat, toll free phone support, and email. I would say that they make more of an effort to keep chat on, compared to Next Day Diploma which was almost unreachable via chat during our entire research.

Shipping and Processing

Phony Diploma did not verify our payment until 10/25/2010. Our diploma was shipped on 10/26/2010 and our package arrived in our mailbox on 10/28/2010, from UPS. Above is photo documentation of our entire purchase experience with Phony Diploma.


Compared to the others, Phony Diploma’s diploma was one of the better ones we received and we were pleased to see the school seal was a match and shiny gold like the real one. On the downside, the school seal itself was on the right hand side which is wrong (it should have been on the left), it had four signatures when there should have just been two, and Phony added a state seal which isn’t accurate because the school we requested was a “private” school and unlike state-run schools, our school would not have featured a state seal.

Phony Diploma may have stocked a different design from a different year, but our request for a matching diploma from the class of 1992 was not met. Diploma Company gets a higher mark for authenticity.

Phony has really been pushing raised seals and emblems hard. We did order a custom diploma with raised gold seals from them and noticed that the gold on the seal was very flaky and looked spotty in places. In contrast, Diploma Company has been pushing the same raised seals and the quality was MUCH BETTER, very sharp and clean. For this we took a few knocks down on quality.


For $275, Phony Diploma was the most expensive order we placed and we may have slightly overpaid. The company does offer a variety of packages to choose from, but we went with their most expensive option, expecting the BEST possible quality. Our total also included a leather graduation folder which said “Diploma of Graduation” in shiny gold. Both my wife and I felt it was a nice added touch as a package deal.

They also didn’t put anything on the diploma or inside the package indicating that it was fake. This gave them a huge boost above some other sites we reviewed.

Proof of Sale